I must say that I'm one of the huge fans of The Big Bang Theory sitcom. What more could we have asked for other than the attractive casts, hilarious show with a brilliant scriptwriting! Well, Dr Sheldon Cooper himself is an interesting character to begin with!
He is usually characterized as extremely intelligent, socially clumsy and strictly logical. Regardless of his intellect, he sometimes displays a lack of common sense. He also possesses childlike qualities which he seems unaware, such as extreme stubbornness. Sheldon also has a broad general knowledge in many subjects. Although his friends have similar intellects to him, his peculiarity, stubbornness and lack of empathy often annoy them. Sheldon occasionally uses slang, and follows jokes with his catchphrase "Bazinga!”. In response to criticism from his friends that he is mentally ill, Sheldon often reply angrily, "I'm not crazy, my mother had me tested”. Like his friends, Sheldon is scientifically of a mind person and is fond of comic books, costumes, role-playing games, video games, customizable card games, action figures, fantasy, and science fiction, particularly Star Trek, in which his favourite character is Spock.
What an interesting character no? Well, he has all the traits of someone with Asperger's Syndrome (not that it is ever mentioned on the show). Several viewers have claimed that Sheldon's behaviour is consistent with Asperger’s syndrome but the writer Bill Prady knows the character better than we do. Prady said that Sheldon does not have Asperger's but instead thought of his actions as "Sheldony" plus, he never had the syndrome in mind when the character was created.
"We write the character as the character. A lot of people see various things in him and make the connections. Our feeling is that Sheldon's mother never got a diagnosis, so we don't have one."
(Bill
Prady)
Does Sheldon have Asperger's?
**this is the best video I could find. The rest are mostly in Spanish I think?
Does Sheldon have Asperger's?
“I do wonder. Okay, so we’re not
writing a character with Asperger’s, but what Aspergerian stories are you
pulling some of this from? I believe one
of our writers has a relative that has Asperger’s. And like I say, I think a lot
of this really intellectual work that somebody like Sheldon does, the way his
brain works, it’s so focused on the intellectual topics at hand that thinking
he’s autistic is an easy leap for people watching the show to make. The way
Sheldon goes “Huh?” to a social and emotional situation because he’s so focused
on what he’s doing. His brain is so wrapped up in it.” (Jim Parsons)
There are good reasons why the writers do not want to label Sheldon as
having Asperger's. Main reason is that if
he's afflicted with the real disease, how can his friends make fun of him the
way they do? Sheldon may be as annoying and fussy but mocking people like him (if
he were to be diagnosed with Asperger's) is not really a brilliant thing to show
to the whole world right? If that is so, then his fellow friends are a bunch of
jerks? Hmmm... If Sheldon did
have a diagnosis, his friends could no longer mock him and I guess the show
would have been banned for life then!
References
Collins, P. (2009,
February 6). Is the world ready for an Asperger's sitcom? Retrieved
November 6, 2012, from Slate Magazine:
http://www.slate.com/articles/arts/television/2009/02/mustgeek_tv.html
Murray, N. (2009, May 1). Interview: Jim Parsons. Retrieved
November 6, 2012, from A.V CLUB:
http://www.avclub.com/articles/jim-parsons,27415/
The Big Bang Theory. (n.d.). Retrieved November
6, 2012, from CBS: http://www.cbs.com/shows/big_bang_theory/about/
Waldman, A. (2009, August 14). Come up with a new theory:
Sheldon does NOT have Asperger's. Retrieved November 6, 2012, from The
Huffington Post:
http://www.aoltv.com/2009/08/14/come-up-with-a-new-theory-sheldon-does-not-have-aspergers
Hi, I like your article!
ReplyDeleteSheldon does have Asperger's
People do have conditions that manifest with 'classic' symptoms AND THEY FAIL TO GET FORMALLY DIAGNOSED AND/OR TREATED!
There is a cash cow at the end of every puzzling road in industrial economies.
Where is the funding for treatment if say 10% of children have this? How would school budgets & social disability insurance cope?
Then we get sinister:
How much more self-medicating dollars would dry up for the friends, family & coworkers, let alone the Asperger's-having person?
Conditions like lupus, autoimmune disease are even thought to be non-existent by some doctors...if those afflicted were recognized, it would be a pandemic.
I think its art imitating life to have everyone including Sheldon fight to deal with undiagnosed & untreated Asperger's. I'm convinced that most people world wide DO NOT receive formal care nor understanding.
By displaying & highlighting Shelly's characteristics, the writers have helped countless people realize that the lack of empathy, high intellect, stubborness, myopic views & child-like behaviour they see in a child or spouse or manager is not unknown as a cluster of symptoms.